Fixing a Dysfunctional Nonprofit Board

Let’s just call it like it is: nonprofit boards can be glorious, maddening, mission-saving, or mission-sinking sometimes all in the same quarter.

You’ve got the micromanager who rewrites staff reports at midnight.
The ghoster who hasn’t shown up since the “Welcome!” email.
And the well-meaning cheerleader who claps for everything… but never lifts a finger.

Sound familiar?

If your board is more “chaotic neutral” than “governance dream team,” you’re not alone, and you’re not stuck. Dysfunction doesn’t mean defeat. It means it’s time for a reset.

Here’s how.

Step 1: Define the Actual Job

Be honest: have you really told your board what you expect from them?

If you’re hoping they’ll fundraise, attend every event, read the financials, and serve as a strategic brain trust—have you said that out loud? In writing?

Start with a clear, no-fluff board member job description. Include expectations like:

• Attend X% of meetings
• Make a personal financial contribution (whatever “meaningful” means to your org)
• Participate on at least one committee
• Support fundraising in specific, bite-sized ways (calls, intros, thank-you notes)
• Act as an ambassador in the community

No more vague “support the mission” language. Be specific. Then share it with every current board member. Yes, even that one.

Step 2: Assess the Current Reality (Gently)

Now that the job is clear… how’s everyone doing?

Use a board self-assessment tool to let folks reflect on their engagement anonymously. Ask things like:

• Do you feel clear on your role and responsibilities?
• Are board meetings productive?
• Do you feel your skills are being used?
• Are you comfortable speaking up?

You may be shocked by how many people are frustrated, but don’t know how to say it. Or think you should just be grateful they’re there.

Spoiler alert: you don’t have time to manage egos. You’re here to serve a mission.

Step 3: Reset the Culture, Not Just the People

This is the big one. Dysfunction isn’t just about individuals, it’s about culture. And culture is what you allow to happen.

So, start fresh:

• Name the reset: “We’re entering a new season as a board. Let’s revisit what we need from each other to thrive.”
• Make meetings matter: Set intentional agendas, assign timekeepers, and keep reports brief. Use the bulk of your time for real conversation and decisions.
• Celebrate progress: Did someone follow through on donor calls? Showed up to an event? Name it. Normalize engagement.
• Enforce boundaries: Micromanaging staff? Politely redirect to the Executive Director. Missing three meetings in a row? Have the “Are you still interested?” conversation.

Step 4: Don’t Be Afraid of the Exit Door

Here’s a secret: your nonprofit deserves an engaged, aligned board. And not everyone fits that bill.

You are allowed to rotate people off. You are allowed to enforce term limits. You are allowed to ask the “sleeping” board members to step down gracefully so you can bring in new energy.

Say it with me: You are not stuck with your current board forever.

Final Thought: Dysfunction Is a Symptom, Not a Diagnosis

You don’t need to burn the whole board down and start over (though hey, sometimes…).
You just need clarity, communication, and a little courage.

So if your board is feeling more Real Housewives than Harvard Business Review, take a breath.

Reset. Reengage. And remember, leadership isn’t always smooth. But with the right tools and a clear path forward, you can absolutely steer the ship.

‍