How to Create a Nonprofit Annual Report That Actually Gets Read

“It’s Annual Report time!”

(Cue the collective groan. I hear you.)

But before you reach for your third cup of coffee or consider hiding under your desk, let’s reframe this. Your Annual Report is not a dreaded task. It is not just something you “have to do.” It is one of your most underutilized tools for showing impact, building trust, and rallying support.

When done well, an Annual Report is a living, breathing celebration of your organization’s mission in action. It is a storybook of impact, a financial report card, and a love letter to your supporters, all rolled into one. And yes, it can be enjoyable to create. No, really.

Let’s talk about how to make one that doesn’t just sit in someone’s downloads folder.

Know Your People

Before you even think about page one, ask yourself: Who is this for? If your answer is “everyone,” let’s take a step back.

Your Annual Report should feel like a one-on-one conversation with the people who matter most to your mission. That includes major donors, monthly supporters, foundation funders, corporate partners, board members, and the people you serve.

Donors want to see how their dollars made a difference. Funders want outcomes and impact. Corporate partners want to see their logo and their value. Volunteers want to see themselves reflected in your wins. And your community? They want to feel proud.

When you know who you’re talking to, you can tailor your tone, your visuals, and your stories to meet them where they are. That’s how you build a report that gets read, remembered, and shared.

Let Your Brand Do the Talking

The moment someone sees your Annual Report, they should know it came from you.

Your logo, your colors, your fonts...this is your visual handshake. Make it consistent with everything else you put out into the world. If you’ve ever walked into a room and immediately spotted someone who felt like “your people,” that’s what your brand should do.

Your report should say, “This is us. This is what we stand for.” From the cover design to the thank-you page, make it unmistakably yours.

Stories That Stick

Now we get to the heart of it.

The most powerful part of your Annual Report is not the financials. It’s not the pie charts or the bulleted lists. It’s the stories.

Tell a story about a family whose life changed because of your food program. Let a volunteer share, in their own words, why they keep showing up. Use names and faces (with permission). Get specific. Because specificity builds trust.

If you say you distributed 12,000 pounds of food, great. But if you say that thanks to a donor-funded fundraiser, you restocked a nearly empty pantry just in time for the holidays, and show the shelves before and after? That’s gold.

Avoid industry jargon and keep the acronyms to a bare minimum. Speak human. Make it clear, warm, and relatable. And before you call it done, have someone outside your organization read it. Ask: Does this reflect the community we serve? Does it sound like us?

Show Me the Money

Your supporters made an investment. They want to know it paid off.

You do not need to bury them in spreadsheets, but you do need to be transparent. Share real numbers in ways that are easy to understand. Include a simple breakdown of revenue and expenses, and maybe a pie chart or two for the visual learners among us.

For those who want more detail (looking at you, funders and accountants), include a QR code that links to your full audited financials online.

And do not forget your call-to-action. Make it bold, clear, and easy. Add a donation link. Mention monthly giving. Offer a phone number for anyone who prefers to talk it out. Your Annual Report is not just a wrap-up, it’s a runway to what’s next.

Embrace the Digital Age

Remember those old-school printed reports that felt like a phone book married a tax return? Let’s leave those in the archives.

Today, your Annual Report can be a sleek, clickable, digital experience. Host it on your website. Share it on social. Email it to your list. That said, keep a few printed copies on hand. Some folks still love to hold something in their hands, and that’s okay too.

And please, I beg you, do not settle for a double-sided Executive Summary and call it a day. Your Annual Report should be a living asset—something you proudly send to funders, hand to a new board member, or pull up during a donor meeting.

Final Thoughts

Yes, I know it’s called an Annual Report, but think of it as a love letter to your mission and everyone who makes it possible.

Make it beautiful. Make it clear. Make it something your supporters look forward to.

Need a little more help? I’ve got you. Download “It’s Annual Report Time!”—your go-to guide for creating a report that informs, inspires, and actually gets read.

Let’s raise the bar on Annual Reports and show the world just how powerful, passionate, and high-impact your nonprofit truly is.

‍